Short let or long-term lease in Italy: which really pays
The two options are very different. The Italian 4+4 lease (four years, renewable for four more) gives a fixed income but ties up the home for years; holiday lets earn more in the right areas but need managing. Here is how to choose.
Updated · 5 min read · Andrea Piva
The comparison in one table
These are the points that usually weigh most in the decision.
| 4+4 lease | Managed holiday let | |
|---|---|---|
| Income | Fixed every month | Variable, higher in tourist areas and cities |
| Risk of unpaid rent | Real, and an eviction takes months | Almost none: guests pay before arriving |
| Using the home yourself | No, for at least 4 years | Yes, you block the dates you want |
| Condition of the home | You see it at the end of the lease | Checked and cleaned after every stay |
| Effort | Low | High on your own, almost none with a manager |
| Tax for private owners | Flat-rate 21% (10% on regulated rents) | Flat-rate 21% on the first home, 26% on the second |
When a holiday let pays
It pays when the home is in an area with tourist or business demand: city centres, the seaside, the lakes, the mountains, near trade fairs, universities and hospitals. It also suits owners who want to use the home a few weeks a year, or keep it free to sell later.
When the 4+4 lease pays
It suits homes in areas with neither tourism nor temporary work, or buildings whose rules forbid tourist rentals. Owners who do not want variable income may prefer it too.
The middle way: transitional leases
There is also the transitional lease (contratto transitorio), from 1 to 18 months, suited to people working away from home and students. In some cities you can alternate: holiday lets in the busy months, a transitional lease in the quiet ones.
How to find out what your home can earn
The most reliable way is a month-by-month estimate based on similar homes in the same area: average nightly price, occupancy, cleaning costs and fees. That is what we do in the free valuation.
Frequently asked questions
Does a holiday let always earn more?
No. It earns more where there is demand: cities, the sea, the lakes and the mountains. In areas without tourism the long-term lease can be the better choice. That is why you need an estimate for the specific home.
Can I switch from a 4+4 lease to holiday lets?
Yes, when the lease ends or with the tenant’s agreement. In the meantime the home can be prepared and the CIN obtained.
This guide is general information and does not replace advice from an Italian accountant (commercialista): tax and local rules change, so always check your own situation.